Tuesday, April 01, 2008

The Post editorial board: It's none of the Ontario's Human Rights Commission's business if York cancels classes for Jewish holidays

Canada's human rights commissions are at it again. In a new report, Ontario's HRC finds Toronto's York University guilty of discrimination. It's 34-year standing policy of cancelling classes on the Jewish holidays of Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur have been deemed unfair. York initiated the practice because Jewish students -- who number about 6% at York -- would not be able to attend classes on those days. But in recent years some university employees have argued that the practice is unfair to the non-Jewish student majority.

We fully agree. It is wholly nonsensical for York to cancel three full days of classes just because a small minority of students will be unable to attend for religious reasons. Far better to arrange special accommodations for those few students who cannot make it to a lecture or tutorial than shut the university down.

That said, this HRC ruling represents yet another example of a commission overstepping its boundary and bowing to pressure from individuals and organizations more bent on limiting our freedoms than strengthening them. York is governed by intelligent, capable people. Its student body is well represented. Together they are more than capable of resolving issues about when the university should and should not cancel classes than Ontario's overzealous human rights watchdog.

4 comments:

truepeers said...

In spirit, I agree with what you say about the university being capable of ruling itself.

But, having served time at York, I have to wonder. After so many years of promoting a certain kind of "multiculturalism" with a lot of victimary thinking, can any university run its own affairs, internally negotiating all or most of its members' differences? Isn't the very nature of the victimary ideologies which much of the faculty promotes that many little disputes cannot be resolved or negotiated by free individuals in decentralized arenas? Isn't the result of encouraging students to think of themselves as absolute victims of the (Western, middle-class, male) normal that they can't negotiate little differences with those structures and persons which are imagined as absolute oppressors?

Rather, all kinds of disputes, however "small", now have to be decided from on high by some kind of imperial agency?

I say get rid of the "Human Rights" agencies and force the university to settle its own disputes internally. And if it can't do that because once one was has give up all of one's own traditions - such as the one dating from the early days of York when it was decided to establish that York would be a Jew-friendly university - and there is now no sense of a shared covenant, or ethic, with which the members of an institution rule themselves, then let the institution fall apart. And let the resentful try and start their own university, and see if they can get the political and social support for it, which will probably require they stop being resentful.

I mean, Western universities are still marked by their foundations in the medieval church. What will happen when all those oppressive roots are truly recognized by the campus victim groups and rooted out? What will happen when Sharia has part-time status on campus? Will the university be more coherent and able to rule itself, or less?

Blazing Cat Fur said...

Given the rank anti-semitism so prevalent at York I'm surprised they don't have a "Protocols of Zion" reading week;)

truepeers said...

Some of it is rank. But much of it is of the subtle variety, like the kind you get from reading Karl Marx (his review on the Jewish Question isn't subtle, but everyone tries to forget that one), Virginia Woolf, or Edward Said, or pretty much any whine against pushy white males and capitalists. That's why they don't have a Protocols week: 1)that book is so highschool (Foucault: now there's a real sophisticated conspiracy theory!); and 2)every week is uncover the "neocon" or "Zionist" week.

Hence the lingering value of any holidays; but bless his Noble soul, David won't let us waste time getting away from our lessons on the big conspiracy that is running this world.

tsfiles said...

"Together they are more than capable of resolving issues about when the university should and should not cancel classes than Ontario's overzealous human rights watchdog."

I tend to agree. Although days off should probably not be given to accomodate 6% of the population, I think this is something the university, its faculty, and students should be able to deal with on their own.

As an American, I'm not that familiar with this Human Rights Commission, but from what I do know about the HRC, it seems that they enjoy inserting their collective nose where it doesn't belong.